Блогчетање

Данилово блогче

Mon, 12 Apr 2004

If you read FootNotes, then you came across this article discussing Dropline Gnome 2.6 (binary distribution of Gnome for Slackware).

What I noticed is the following excerpt:

With the license change to XFree86 4.4, Dropline GNOME has also joined the revolution and moved to X.Org's X11 server (don't worry, the nVidia and ATI binary drivers still work).

How is anyone so clueless allowed to even make a statement such as this? XFree86 4.4 has licence changed so it is not completely free software anymore (actually, the main bottleneck is that it's incompatible with GPL, or, you cannot combine GPL pieces with it because of a new term in a licence). Yet, this smart guy who wrote the comment thinks it's all right to use binary nVidia and ATI drivers, yet it's not all right to use (almost) free software coming from XFree86?

The "revolution" that is happening is caused by slow pace of development in XFree86 (actually, not of development, but of accepting grand new features). Licence change has caused vendors to move from XFree86, but that's a non-issue if we're talking about [technical] "revolution". All of the changes in FreeDesktop's (perhaps even "Keith Packard's") server, mistakenly called "X.Org" (probably because XFree86 provides access to CVS in a "xorg" module, which is therefore used on FreeDesktop's X server implementation derived from XFree86's one), are equally applicable to XFree86 repository; they simply aren't merged back yet. So, all revolution there is will equally apply to XFree86 as to any other server.

This is also where we see GPL at work: as soon as XFree got licence incompatible with GPL, we saw a fork. Yeah, there was talk of fork even earlier, but it failed to materialize until it became inevitable, in order to make it possible to distribute whole free operating system stack on a single CD, without having to adhere to obscure conditions such as putting a name of contributor which provided 100 lines of code on each disk.

[23:07] | [/razno] | # | G | | TB
Contact
Danilo Segan

This is blog (web log) of Danilo Šegan (or Данило Шеган).

Archives
2017-Jan
2013-Dec
2011-Nov
2011-Oct
2011-Aug
2011-Jul
2011-Jun
2011-May
2010-Oct
2010-Aug
2010-Jul
2010-Apr
2010-Mar
2010-Feb
2010-Jan
2009-Dec
2009-Oct
2009-Aug
2009-Jun
2008-Oct
2008-Aug
2008-Jul
2008-Jun
2008-May
2008-Apr
2008-Mar
2008-Feb
2007-Dec
2007-Oct
2007-Aug
2007-Jul
2007-May
2007-Apr
2007-Feb
2007-Jan
2006-Nov
2006-Oct
2006-Aug
2006-Jul
2006-Apr
2006-Mar
2006-Feb
2006-Jan
2005-Sep
2005-Jun
2005-May
2005-Apr
2005-Mar
2005-Feb
2004-Dec
2004-Nov
2004-Oct
2004-Sep
2004-Aug
2004-Jul
2004-May
2004-Apr
2004-Mar
2004-Feb
2004-Jan
2003-Dec
2003-Nov
2003-Oct
2003-Sep
1983-Mar

< April 2004 >
MoTuWeThFrSaSu
    1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 91011
12131415161718
19202122232425
2627282930  
Categories

Links
Kvota.net
Prevod.org
My study page
Srpski.org
GNOME
Friends' Blogs
alex (en)
bc (en)
Bojan Živanović (sr)
Carlos (en)
Goran (sr)
imp (sr)
lilit (sr)
Oskuro (en)
Zombie (sr/en)
Feeds
RSS